Diagnosis or Death (Janna Rose Mysteries Book 2)

5 Star Review

Click HERE to Purchase Your Copy Today!

Editorial Book Review:

By Sandra Williams

There is something particularly unsettling about a mystery that uses the machinery of everyday life as its weapon. Not a shadowy criminal underworld, not an exotic location, but a welfare benefits office, a psychology assessment form, a system that vulnerable people depend on just to survive. That is the terrain Jake Lynch and Annabel McGoldrick chose for Diagnosis or Death, and it gives the book a weight that lingers well past the final page.

Reading it produces a slow-building unease that is quite different from the shock-driven tension of most contemporary thrillers. The danger here accumulates through bureaucratic pressure, through small wrongnesses that Janna notices before she can name them, through the creeping realization that the systems meant to protect people can be quietly turned against them. By the time the deepfakes and artificial intelligence enter the picture, the groundwork has been so carefully laid that the escalation feels inevitable rather than sensational.

What Lynch and McGoldrick are really writing about sits well beyond the mechanics of any single crime. The novel asks hard questions about trust in institutional systems, about how easily identity and truth can be manufactured in the digital age, and about what it costs to be the person in the room who refuses to look away. Janna's background as both journalist and therapist gives her a particular way of reading people and situations, and that dual lens makes her investigation feel psychologically rich rather than procedurally routine.

The Oxford setting carries its familiar literary associations but the authors use them shrewdly, placing a very modern crisis inside a city that projects permanence and authority. That contrast is doing real thematic work throughout.

The writing is sharp and socially alert without ever becoming preachy. The authors clearly care about the vulnerable people at the edges of this story, and that care gives the mystery its emotional backbone.

For readers who want their crime fiction to mean something beyond the puzzle, this is exactly where to look.

About the Author 

Jake Lynch

Jake Lynch is an Associate Professor at the University of Sydney, where he teaches into the Master of Social Justice degree. A former BBC World Television newsreader and award-winning international journalist, he was honoured with the Luxembourg Peace Prize in 2017 for his work on Peace Journalism. He divides his time between Australia and Oxford, which is the setting for his novels. The latest, Mind Over Murder, published by Next Chapter, is co-authored with his partner, Annabel McGoldrick. His poems have appeared in literary journals including Pulsebeat and Collaborature.