The Detective and Dorothy Day: A Novel

5 Star Review

Click HERE to Purchase Your Copy Today!

Editorial Book Review:

By William Reimers

Some crime novels chase answers. The Detective and Dorothy Day chases conscience. Robert C. Conner takes the familiar shape of a hardboiled investigation and threads it through real history, moral tension, and the presence of a woman whose convictions still echo decades later. What makes this novel stand out is not just the murder at its center, but the collision between streetwise cynicism and radical compassion.

It feels like there are layers to it and it doesn't stop moving. It has the grit of a detective story from the 1970s, with smoky bars, shaky alliances, and a growing sense of danger. But it does make you think. Sy Johnson has to talk to people who make him doubt what he thinks and feels as he looks into corruption and damage to the environment. The emotional flow goes from not believing to thinking about yourself. The reader isn't sure if justice is revenge or a way to make things right. There is still this tension.

The book talks about themes like taking responsibility, waking up morally, workers' rights, ignoring the environment, and finding personal redemption. Conner adds the historical figure of Dorothy Day to the story to make it more than just one case. What does it mean to stick to your beliefs even when things aren't going well? These thoughts go beyond the story. They talk to anyone who is having trouble meeting their own needs while also doing their job.

Conner's writing is dark, but it gets better when he takes breaks to think. His pacing makes things tense, but it also gives people room to talk deeply. The story has a subtle rhythm because the city scenes are so different from the calm setting of the Catholic Worker farm. Imagery about decay and renewal gives the investigation more depth without making the story too heavy.

In the end, The Detective and Dorothy Day leaves a lasting mark because it doesn't separate crime from morality. It has both stress and thoughtfulness. This book is rewarding, makes you think, and is surprisingly human for people who like mysteries that make them think as well as entertain them.